Spawn and Substrates

Manure-Loving Mushrooms and Manure-Based Substrates

Which edible mushrooms grow on manure and compost, how manure-based substrate is prepared, why mushrooms appear in compost, and what to avoid.

On this page
  1. What “manure-loving” means
  2. Edible mushrooms that grow on manure or compost
  3. Wild dung-loving mushrooms: why to be careful
  4. Preparing manure-based substrate
  5. Why are there mushrooms growing in my compost?
  6. FAQ

What “manure-loving” means

Some fungi are saprotrophs that specialize in breaking down well-rotted animal dung, composted manure or compost-like mixtures. Their natural food is rich in nitrogen and partly broken down by bacteria before the fungus takes over. In cultivation, “manure-loving” usually refers to species grown on composted manure, often mixed with straw, rather than on raw wood or sawdust.

Edible mushrooms that grow on manure or compost

  • Button, cremini and portobello (Agaricus bisporus). These are the best-known example, and the commercial crop is grown on a composted mixture of straw and manure with a “casing” layer applied on top. Home growers often start with a pre-colonized kit.
  • Almond mushroom (Agaricus subrufescens). Related to the button mushroom and grown on similar composted material, often at warmer temperatures. Experience helps with this one.
  • Shaggy mane (Coprinus comatus). Often found in disturbed ground and on well-manured soil. It can be cultivated, but its caps self-digest into black liquid within hours of maturing, so it does not store or ship well.
  • Straw mushroom (Volvariella volvacea). Traditionally grown on rice straw or similar plant waste in warm climates, and sometimes on compost-type material.
  • Wine cap (Stropharia rugosoannulata). Strictly a wood chip and straw mushroom, but it is often grown in garden beds amended with compost, and it appears in discussions of “compost mushrooms.”

Which materials a species accepts varies, so check the guidance for the strain you buy. For a broader comparison of materials, see the best substrate for mushroom cultivation.

Wild dung-loving mushrooms: why to be careful

Many mushrooms found on dung and manure in the wild are inedible, and some are psychoactive or toxic. Many look alike, and an error in identification can be dangerous. As a rule, do not eat a wild mushroom unless an experienced local expert has identified it for you.

Some dung-loving species contain psilocybin, which is a controlled substance in many places, and growing them is illegal in many jurisdictions. This site covers culinary species only and does not give instructions for restricted species.

Preparing manure-based substrate

Fresh manure is not used directly. It is composted first so that heat and microbes break it down. A commonly described approach for button mushroom compost, as outlined by several growing guides, is:

  1. Use well-aged horse manure (or a similar source) mixed with wet straw.
  2. Pile it so it can heat up, and turn it regularly, for example every couple of days, over a period of a few weeks.
  3. The finished compost should be dark brown and smell sweet rather than sharp or ammonia-like.
  4. Spread it in a tray to a few inches deep, add spawn, and keep it warm and moist.
  5. Once the mycelium has colonized the compost, cover it with a casing layer (a damp, low-nutrient layer such as peat-free compost mixed with a little lime) and then adjust temperature and humidity for fruiting.

Commercial growers follow more tightly controlled compost phases. Manure-based material is also naturally alkaline, so pH can matter; see substrate pH for mushroom growing.

If you use any pre-made manure product, check that it is pasteurized or sterilized and follow the instructions for your species. Where you pasteurize your own material, the general principles in how to pasteurize straw are a useful starting point, though temperatures and times differ for manure.

Why are there mushrooms growing in my compost?

Compost and mulch are full of decaying organic matter, which is what saprotrophic fungi feed on. The mycelium is often there all along, and mushrooms appear when moisture and temperature are right. In most cases they are harmless to your plants, and they are a sign of active decomposition. You can remove them if you wish. Do not eat them unless a qualified expert has identified them, since compost mushrooms can be toxic.

FAQ

What are edible dung-loving mushrooms? Species like the cultivated Agaricus group and shaggy mane are commonly eaten, but for safety stay with cultivated strains from reputable suppliers rather than foraging dung-growing species.

What US state grows the most mushrooms? Pennsylvania is the largest producer of mushrooms in the United States, and most of its crop is Agaricus bisporus grown on composted substrate.

What is the best substrate for mushroom cultivation? It depends on the species. Button mushrooms prefer composted manure, while oysters, shiitake and lion’s mane favor straw or hardwood.

The complete guide to spawn and substrates

Mushroom Spawn Explained: Grain Spawn Sawdust Spawn and Mycelium
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →