Why pH matters
pH measures how acidic or alkaline something is, on a scale where 7 is neutral. Mycelium tends to grow best within a particular range, and many competing molds and bacteria thrive in different ranges. A substrate that is far outside the range for your species can slow colonization or give contaminants an opening. Most home growers can get good results without ever measuring pH, but understanding it helps with troubleshooting, especially when you use lime, manure or other materials that push it up or down.
Approximate ideal ranges
Most cultivated mushrooms are reported to prefer a slightly acidic to near-neutral substrate, with a commonly cited overall range of roughly 5.5 to 7.0. Sources differ, and the ranges below are approximate guidance rather than strict rules:
- Oyster mushrooms: about 6.0 to 7.5, and they are known for tolerating a wider range than most.
- Shiitake: more acidic, around 5.0 to 6.5.
- Lion’s mane and reishi: around 5.5 to 6.5.
- Enoki: around 6.0 to 6.8.
- Button and portobello (Agaricus bisporus): they are grown on composted manure and straw, which is typically neutral to alkaline. See manure-loving mushrooms.
Check the guidance from your spawn supplier for your specific strain.
Typical pH of common substrates
Materials differ in their natural pH. Approximate values often cited:
- Hardwood sawdust: roughly 5.0 to 6.5
- Coco coir: roughly 5.5 to 6.2
- Straw: roughly 6.0 to 7.0
- Manure and compost: can be 7.5 to 8.5 or higher, which is alkaline
Values vary with the exact material, its age and the water used. For a comparison of materials by species, see the best substrate for mushroom cultivation.
Do you need to test?
Often not. If you follow an established recipe from a reliable source, such as Master’s Mix, the ingredients are chosen to fall in a workable range. Testing becomes more useful when you:
- use unfamiliar materials or an unusual blend
- add lime, gypsum or other amendments
- repeatedly have contamination problems with no clear cause
- grow on soil, compost or other highly variable materials
How to measure
Options include pH test strips, a handheld pH meter, or a soil-style test kit. Test a slurry: mix a small sample of the moist substrate with distilled water, let it stand for a few minutes, then test the liquid. Meters need calibration with buffer solutions. Strips are cheaper but less precise, and colored or cloudy slurries can be hard to read.
How to adjust
Adjusting is usually done in small steps, mixing thoroughly and re-testing.
- To raise pH: hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide) or calcium carbonate are commonly used. Hydrated lime can irritate skin, eyes and lungs, so wear gloves and a mask.
- To lower pH: citric acid or elemental sulfur are sometimes used. Sulfur works slowly.
Add small amounts, because it is easy to overshoot, and keep careful notes so you can repeat what worked.
pH and pasteurization
Cold-water lime pasteurization works partly by raising the pH of the soaking water to a level most competitors tolerate poorly. The straw is then drained so the pH falls back before you add spawn. The method is covered in how to pasteurize straw for mushroom growing.
FAQ
Is growing mushrooms in soil good? Most cultivated gourmet mushrooms feed on wood, straw or compost, not on ordinary garden soil. Some species, such as wine cap (Stropharia rugosoannulata), can be grown in garden beds with wood chips or straw. Plain soil is not usually a good primary substrate.
What is the most difficult mushroom to grow? Mycorrhizal species such as truffles and chanterelles, which depend on living tree roots, are widely regarded as very hard to cultivate at home. Of common culinary mushrooms, oysters are usually considered the easiest.
What is the best pH for plant growth? Many garden plants do well at around 6.0 to 7.0, but the right figure depends on the plant. Mushrooms are fungi, so their ranges and substrates differ from garden plants.