The mushroom most people eat without thinking about it is Agaricus bisporus. It is sold as white button, brown cremini (or baby bella) and portobello. These are not three species but one species at different sizes, ages or strains. This page explains how it is classified, what its mycelium looks like and how its cultivation differs from most other gourmet mushrooms.
Classification of the button mushroom
A widely used classification runs as follows (for what each rank means, see the 7 levels of classification for a mushroom):
- Kingdom: Fungi
- Phylum: Basidiomycota
- Class: Agaricomycetes
- Order: Agaricales
- Family: Agaricaceae
- Genus: Agaricus
- Species: Agaricus bisporus
The “bisporus” part refers to the fact that the spore-producing cells typically bear two spores, compared with four in many related mushrooms (see how mushrooms reproduce). Some wild relatives, including the field mushroom and horse mushroom, belong to the same genus, and some other Agaricus species cause stomach upset, so wild identification needs an expert.
If someone asks “what kind of mushroom is a white mushroom,” the typical answer is a white-strain Agaricus bisporus. The word “group” is used loosely for mushrooms: a cluster growing together is often called a flush or cluster, and a related set of species is a genus.
Button, cremini and portobello are one species
- White button: a white-capped strain, harvested while the cap is closed over the gills.
- Cremini or baby bella: a brown-capped strain, usually harvested in a similar young stage, with a slightly firmer texture and deeper flavor to many palates.
- Portobello: a mature brown-capped form with a fully open cap and exposed gills.
Differences in appearance come from strain, maturity and, to some extent, light exposure. That is why a grower who wants portobellos will usually leave a brown strain to grow larger rather than buy a separate type of spawn.
How to identify a portobello
A portobello is a large, flat, open-capped Agaricus bisporus with a dark brown cap and visible gills that are brown to dark chocolate. The stem is short and sturdy. In shops the name usually describes the fully mature cultivated mushroom. Identifying a mushroom you find outdoors is a different task: do not eat a wild mushroom because it looks like a portobello. Have an expert check it in person.
Portobello mushroom mycelium
Mycelium is the network of fine threads that makes up the main body of the fungus. Individual threads (hyphae) are microscopic, but a mass of mycelium can be seen with the naked eye as white, cottony or thread-like growth in the compost or substrate. In Agaricus it often looks like fine white strands running through the compost, and it can thicken into a denser mat. It has the same appearance whether the final mushrooms will be buttons or portobellos, because they are the same species.
How Agaricus is grown
Agaricus bisporus differs from oyster, shiitake and most other cultivated species, because it feeds on composted material rather than raw wood or straw. The standard commercial process, in simplified form:
- Compost. A mix, commonly of straw and manure or other nitrogen sources (see manure-loving mushrooms and manure-based substrates), is composted so that heat and microbes change it into a medium that suits Agaricus and not much else.
- Spawn run. Spawn is mixed in and the mycelium colonizes the compost, usually at a warm temperature.
- Casing. The colonized compost is covered with a thin layer of a casing material, often peat-based with lime. The mycelium grows into it, and the casing helps hold moisture and plays a part in triggering fruiting.
- Fruiting. Lower temperatures, more fresh air and consistent humidity prompt pins. Growers often work in the low-to-mid 60s °F range, although recommendations vary by strain.
- Harvest. Pick mushrooms by twisting them out. Harvest buttons while the veil is still closed. Leave some to grow larger if you want portobellos.
The mushroom’s history is closely tied to cool, stable places. Cultivation is commonly traced back to 17th-century France, where growers used melon beds and later the limestone quarries beneath Paris.
Home growing options
Most home growers buy a kit with colonized compost and a casing layer, then keep it somewhere cool and shaded while it fruits. Basements and cool closets work in many homes. Homemade compost is possible but takes more space, and the smell and the work make it a less common choice for hobbyists.
Button or oyster: which costs more?
Retail prices vary a lot by country, season and shop. In many places buttons are cheaper than specialty mushrooms such as oysters, because production of Agaricus is enormous and highly industrialized. If you want a price per kilogram, check your local shops, since any number published online will be out of date or wrong for your area. For the oyster side of the comparison, see growing oyster mushrooms.
What is the hardest mushroom to grow?
Opinions differ, but morels are widely seen as the hardest, as discussed in can you grow morel mushrooms. Agaricus is moderately demanding because it needs compost and cool conditions. A wider ranking is in what is the most difficult mushroom to grow. For comparison across species, see gourmet mushrooms to grow at home.