Getting Started

Growing Mushrooms From Store-Bought Mushrooms: What Works and What Doesn't

Oysters can often be cloned from fresh store-bought stems. Learn which mushrooms work, which usually don't, and how the cardboard, coffee and agar methods compare.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Why it can work
  3. Which store-bought mushrooms work best
  4. Which usually don’t
  5. Method 1: cardboard
  6. Method 2: coffee grounds
  7. Method 3: tissue culture on agar
  8. From culture to mushrooms: scaling up
  9. What to expect and common failures
  10. Is it worth it compared with buying spawn?

Short answer

Sometimes. Fresh store-bought oyster mushrooms are the usual success story, and with luck a stem base can be used to start a new culture that grows on cardboard, coffee grounds or straw. Other species, such as shiitake and king oyster, may also work with more care. The common white button, cremini and portobello mushrooms are generally much less suitable for home cloning, and success is never guaranteed. If your goal is a reliable harvest, buying spawn or a kit is usually easier.

Why it can work

A mushroom is the fruiting body of a fungus, and the base of the stem is often still living tissue connected to the mycelium. If you place a small piece of living tissue on a suitable food source and keep it clean and moist, it can regrow as mycelium, a process called cloning. This is different from growing from spores. Spores are slower, more variable and harder for beginners, so most guides use tissue cloning instead. If you are curious about the spore route, see whether you can grow mushrooms from a spore print. For the basics of spawn and substrate, see how to grow mushrooms at home.

Which store-bought mushrooms work best

  • Oyster mushrooms (blue, pink, golden and others) are the best bet. See growing oyster mushrooms. The mycelium is vigorous, tends to colonize cardboard, straw and coffee grounds quickly, and is fairly tolerant of contaminants.
  • Shiitake can work, though it is slower and fussier, and usually prefers hardwood sawdust or logs.
  • King oyster is possible, but it is a more demanding species when fruiting.
  • Lion’s mane is sometimes sold fresh and can be cloned, though success varies.

Choose mushrooms that are fresh, firm and unblemished, ideally with a stem base that has not been trimmed too aggressively. Organic or locally grown ones may be fresher, though that is not a guarantee. Mushrooms that have been treated, irradiated, dried, canned or heavily aged are poor candidates.

Which usually don’t

  • Button, cremini and portobello are the same species at different stages (see button and portobello mushrooms). They grow on composted material, not on cardboard or sawdust, and they are harder to clone and fruit at home. Commercial strains are also selected for specific production systems.
  • Enoki in stores is often grown for a specific cold, low-light system, and cloned cultures may not reproduce the look.
  • Wild-type mushrooms and mycorrhizal species, such as chanterelles, are generally not practical. See the most difficult mushrooms to grow.
  • Old, slimy or dried mushrooms are unlikely to have living tissue.

Method 1: cardboard

This is the simplest method, and it is often used for oysters.

  1. Choose fresh oyster mushrooms and cut off the bottom of the stems.
  2. Soak plain corrugated cardboard (no glossy coating or colored ink) in hot water, let it cool, and peel back a layer to expose the ridges.
  3. Place the stem bases between the layers of damp cardboard.
  4. Put it in a container or bag with some air holes. Keep it damp, dark and at a comfortable room temperature, commonly around 65 to 75°F (18 to 24°C).
  5. After about two to four weeks, you may see white mycelium spreading through the cardboard.

If you see green, black or pink mold, or smell something sour, discard it. See green mold on mushroom substrate.

Method 2: coffee grounds

  1. Use fresh, used coffee grounds. Boiling them for about 20 minutes or using freshly brewed grounds reduces competitors. Let them cool.
  2. Layer them into a clean jar with pieces of fresh mushroom stem or cap.
  3. Close loosely, keep in a dark spot and wait for white mycelium to spread.
  4. Once the jar is mostly colonized, mix it into a larger container of pasteurized straw or wood shavings.

Coffee grounds are rich and also attractive to molds, so this method may have a lower success rate than cardboard. More detail is in growing mushrooms on coffee grounds.

Method 3: tissue culture on agar

This is the more controlled approach used by experienced hobbyists. A full walkthrough is in how to clone mushrooms onto agar from tissue.

  1. Prepare nutrient agar in dishes and sterilize them.
  2. Break open a fresh mushroom and take a small piece of tissue from inside, away from the outside surface.
  3. Place it on the agar in a clean setting, such as a still-air box.
  4. Wait for mycelium to grow out, and transfer clean sections to new dishes if contaminants appear.
  5. Use clean mycelium to inoculate sterilized grain, making spawn.
  6. Use that spawn to inoculate bulk substrate.

Agar work lets you isolate clean cultures and test for contaminants early. It needs sterile technique and equipment, and it adds cost and learning time.

From culture to mushrooms: scaling up

A piece of cardboard with mycelium is not yet a harvest. You generally need to expand it:

  • Move colonized cardboard into pasteurized straw or another suitable substrate, such as sawdust, and keep it moist.
  • Keep it in the colonization conditions until it is mostly white.
  • Switch to fruiting conditions (fresh air, humidity, indirect light). See mushroom growing conditions.

Expect it to take longer than using purchased spawn, and be prepared for some batches to fail. For typical timelines, see how fast mushrooms grow.

What to expect and common failures

  • Contamination: the most common problem, since grocery mushrooms carry bacteria and mold, and the stem base is rarely clean.
  • No growth: the mushroom may be too old, treated, or not a good species for cloning.
  • Weak or slow mycelium: a cloned culture might be less vigorous than commercial spawn, which is selected and tested.
  • Unknown genetics: you will not know the strain, and it may not fruit as productively as a purchased strain.
  • Limited yield: home-cloned cultures that do work often produce modest harvests.

Is it worth it compared with buying spawn?

Cloning a store-bought mushroom is a fun, low-cost experiment, and it teaches useful skills. It is not the most reliable path. Spawn from a reputable supplier has selected genetics and has been grown in clean conditions, so it saves time and frustration. For a look at what each route costs, see how much it costs to start growing mushrooms at home. A sensible approach is to try cloning with oysters as a side project while using a kit or purchased spawn for the main grow.

The complete guide to getting started

How to Grow Mushrooms at Home: The Complete Process
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →