No single color is best for everyone. For most beginners, the blue or grey (pearl) oyster is a dependable first choice because it tolerates a wide range of conditions (see mushroom growing conditions). Golden and pink oysters are favorites for color and are best suited to warmer rooms. Phoenix oysters suit warmer climates and are often chosen for their lighter caps and mild flavor.
Quick comparison
| Variety | Species (usually) | Color | Temperature tendency | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blue / pearl / grey | Pleurotus ostreatus | Blue-grey, fading to tan-grey | Cooler to moderate | Often the easiest and most forgiving |
| Golden | Pleurotus citrinopileatus | Bright yellow | Warm | Delicate, eye-catching, cluster easily |
| Pink | Pleurotus djamor | Pink to salmon | Warm to hot | Fast, tropical, short shelf life |
| Phoenix (Indian) | Pleurotus pulmonarius | Cream to light grey or tan | Moderate to warm | Often chosen for summer growing |
Species and strain can differ between sellers, so use these as general guidelines.
Blue or pearl oyster
This is the classic oyster. Caps start bluish-grey and fade to grey-brown or tan as they age and as temperatures rise. Many growers regard the blue types as the most forgiving, since they handle cooler weather and fruit dependably. The texture is meaty and the flavor is generally described as mild.
If you want one variety to learn on, this is a sensible choice. For how oysters are grown from culture to harvest, see growing oyster mushrooms.
Golden oyster
Golden oysters are bright yellow and form dense, ruffled clusters. They usually prefer warmer fruiting temperatures and tend to be more delicate, and the color can fade as they mature. Many people describe the flavor as slightly nutty, though that is a matter of taste. They look good on a plate and at a market stall.
Pink oyster
Pink oysters are a tropical species. They grow fast in warm conditions, which makes them a good fit for hot climates or summer growing, but they do not like the cold. See how fast mushrooms grow. They are fragile and do not store as long as other oysters, so they are best eaten soon after harvest. The pink color fades when cooked, which surprises some cooks.
Phoenix oyster
Phoenix oysters, sold under Pleurotus pulmonarius, have lighter, cream-to-tan caps and are often chosen for warmer-weather growing. They look similar to pearl oysters but often have smaller caps. They are sometimes called Italian, summer or Indian oysters.
King oyster
King oysters (Pleurotus eryngii) are not usually listed by color. They are grown for a thick, meaty stem and a small tan cap. They need a different approach, which is covered in growing king oyster mushrooms.
How to choose
- Cool room or cooler climate: blue or pearl oysters.
- Warm room or hot summers: golden, pink or phoenix. Seasonal timing is covered in what time of year to plant mushroom spawn.
- Learning your first grow: blue or pearl.
- Display or market appeal: golden or pink, with the caveat that both are more perishable.
- Selling: check what local buyers want before you plan a crop. Some varieties sell well because of color, others because of shelf life. See what is the most lucrative mushroom to grow.
Whatever you choose, make sure your spawn is fresh. How long oyster mushroom spawn lasts covers how to tell.